Current:Home > ScamsJudge rather than jury will render verdict in upcoming antitrust trial-LoTradeCoin
Judge rather than jury will render verdict in upcoming antitrust trial
View Date:2024-12-23 21:34:39
ALEXANDRIA, Va. (AP) — A judge rather than a jury will decide whether Google violated federal antitrust laws by building a monopoly on the technology that powers online advertising.
The decision Friday by U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema was a defeat for the Justice Department, which sought a jury trial when it filed the case last year in federal court in Alexandria, Virginia.
But the government’s right to a jury trial was based largely on the fact that it sought monetary damages to compensate federal agencies that purchased online ads and claimed they were overcharged as a result of Google’s anticompetitive conduct. The dollar values associated with those claims, though, were relatively small — less than $750,000 — and far less significant than other remedies sought by the government, which might include forcing Google to sell off parts of its advertising technology.
As a result, Google last month took the extraordinary step of writing the government a check for more than $2 million — the $750,000 in damages claimed by the government multiplied by three because antitrust cases allow for trebled damages.
Mountain View, California-based Google argued that writing the check rendered moot any government claim of monetary damages and eliminated the need for a jury trial.
At a hearing Friday in Alexandria, Justice Department lawyers argued that the check Google wrote was insufficient to moot the damages claim, prompting a technical discussion over how experts would try to quantify the damages.
Brinkema ruled in favor of Google. She said the amount of Google’s check covered the highest possible amount the government had sought in its initial filings. She likened receipt of the money, which was paid unconditionally to the government regardless of whether the tech giant prevailed in its arguments to strike a jury trial, as equivalent to “receiving a wheelbarrow of cash.”
Google said in a statement issued after Friday’s hearing it is “glad the Court ruled that this case will be tried by a judge. As we’ve said, this case is a meritless attempt to pick winners and losers in a highly competitive industry that has contributed to overwhelming economic growth for businesses of all sizes.”
In its court papers, Google also argued that the constitutional right to a jury trial does not apply to a civil suit brought by the government. The government disagreed with that assertion but said it would not seek a ruling from the judge on that constitutional question.
The antitrust trial in Virginia is separate from a case in the District of Columbia alleging Google’s search engine is an illegal monopoly. A judge there has heard closing arguments in that case but has not yet issued a verdict.
veryGood! (5)
Related
- John Krasinski named People magazine’s 2024 Sexiest Man Alive
- What does it mean to claim the US is a Christian nation, and what does the Constitution say?
- Hilary Swank Cuddles Twin Babies Ohm and Aya in Sweet New Photo
- 18 elementary students, teacher fall ill after dry ice experiment in Tennessee classroom
- Florida Man Arrested for Cold Case Double Murder Almost 50 Years Later
- Trump’s legal debts top a half-billion dollars. Will he have to pay?
- NBA All-Star 3-point contest 2024: Time, how to watch, participants, rules
- UConn basketball star Paige Bueckers is returning for another season: 'Not done yet'
- 32 things we learned in NFL Week 10: Who will challenge for NFC throne?
- Explosion at Virginia home kills 1 firefighter and hospitalizes 9 firefighters and 2 civilians
Ranking
- FanDuel Sports Network regional channels will be available as add-on subscription on Prime Video
- Dandelions and shrubs to replace rubber, new grains and more: Are alternative crops realistic?
- FYI, Anthropologie Is Having an Extra 40% Off On Over 3,000 Sale Items (& It's Not Just Decor)
- In MLB jersey controversy, cheap-looking new duds cause a stir across baseball
- 'SNL' stars jokingly declare support for Trump, Dana Carvey plays Elon Musk
- Why Paris Hilton's World as a Mom of 2 Kids Is Simply the Sweetest
- 4 men dead following drive-by shooting in Alabama, police say
- NBA commissioner for a day? Vince Staples has some hilarious ideas – like LeBron throwing a chair
Recommendation
-
See Blake Shelton and Gwen Stefani's Winning NFL Outing With Kids Zuma and Apollo
-
State governments looking to protect health-related data as it’s used in abortion battle
-
George Kliavkoff out as Pac-12 commissioner as the full conference enters final months
-
Winter Beauty Hack- Get $20 off Isle of Paradise Self-Tanning Drops and Enjoy a Summer Glow All Year Long
-
Florida State can't afford to fire Mike Norvell -- and can't afford to keep him
-
13 men, including an American, arrested at Canada hotel and charged with luring minors for sexual abuse
-
George Kliavkoff out as Pac-12 commissioner as the full conference enters final months
-
Q&A: Everyday Plastics Are Making Us Sick—and Costing Us $250 Billion a Year in Healthcare